FlyKiki mascot

Cheap Flights from New York to Cayman Islands

3-8 hours direct flight. Airlines: JetBlue, American Airlines, Delta +2 more. Fares from $250.

Get New York to Cayman Islands Deals→

100% Free - Join 10,000+ deal hunters

New York to Cayman Islands Flight Overview

✈️

Flight Details

  • Duration: 3-8 hours direct
  • Direct Flights: Yes
  • From: JFK, LGA, EWR
  • To: GCM
💰

Typical Prices

  • Economy: $250-600 roundtrip
  • Cheapest: September, October, November
  • Priciest: December, January, February

Airlines Flying New York to Cayman Islands

JetBlueAmerican AirlinesDeltaUnitedSouthwest
💰

Get Cayman Islands Flight Deals in Your Inbox

Join thousands of travelers who save $400+ on average. We find the deals, you take the trips.

100% free • No spam • Unsubscribe anytime

Tips for Cheap New York to Cayman Islands Flights

1Cayman Airways offers direct flights from JFK several times weekly at 4 hours 45 minutes. Book directly through their website for lower fares and better schedule flexibility compared to booking through third-party aggregators.
2JetBlue operates seasonal nonstop service from JFK with lower fares ($300-500 round-trip during sales) and better onboard amenities. Check their route schedule as service frequency varies by season, with more flights during winter months.
3Travel during shoulder seasons (late April to early June or September to October) for savings of $200-400 and fewer crowds. Hurricane season (August to October) has lowest fares but weather risks. Winter (December to March) is peak season with premium pricing.
4Book at least 6-8 weeks ahead for best selection and pricing. Last-minute bookings (under 2 weeks) can cost double during peak season. Tuesday and Wednesday departures are typically $100-200 cheaper than Friday through Monday travel.
5Consider connecting through Miami if direct flights are expensive. American and United offer frequent Miami connections at competitive rates, though you'll add 2-3 hours total travel time. Sometimes this routing saves $200-300 on your ticket.

💡Savings tip: Book 6-8 weeks ahead for the best New York to Cayman Islands fares. Flexibility with dates can save you 20-30%.

FAQs About Flights to New York to Cayman Islands

Yes, both Cayman Airways and JetBlue offer nonstop service from JFK to Grand Cayman (GCM), taking about 4 hours 45 minutes. Cayman Airways flies year-round, while JetBlue operates seasonally with more frequent service during winter months (November to April).

Never Miss a Deal to Cayman Islands

Join 12,000+ deal hunters. Get notified when prices drop.

Explore Our Full Cayman Islands Travel Guide

Planning your trip? Our Cayman Islands guide covers where to stay, must-try foods, top attractions, daily costs, getting around, and more - no matter where you're flying from.

Cayman Islands Travel Guide→

More Flights from New York

TokyoParisCancunBarcelonaDubaiBaliAmsterdamBangkok